NHL stars push for Gary Bettman to abolish the league's most disputed rule

PUBLICATION

Gabriel Sami
August 26, 2024 (10:24)

SHARE THIS STORY

Many NHL players, including Samuel Ersson and Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen, are questioning the fairness of the shootout rule, leading to discussions about potential changes.

The NHL's shootout rule has long been a topic of debate among fans and players alike. While the thrilling 3 on 3 overtime segment is widely appreciated, the shootout that follows is often criticized. This format, which determines the outcome after a five-minute overtime period, pits players one-on-one against goaltenders, raising concerns about fairness and effectiveness.

Per the insightful Elliotte Friedman, a notable number of players are calling for the elimination of the shootout. This sentiment is shared by notable goaltenders Samuel Ersson and Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen, who argue that the one-on-one format puts goalies at a significant disadvantage. The lack of defensive support and the spotlight on goaltending during these shootouts can make the situation feel disproportionately challenging.

Additionally, players like David Pastrnak have expressed dissatisfaction with the current system, noting that game-winning goals scored during the shootout are not credited to a player's statistics. This aspect is particularly frustrating in a league where personal achievements are highly valued.

Tried to ask every player if there's one thing they'd want to change about the NHL. Several, especially the younger ones, basically said, «What do I have to complain about? I'm living my dream, and making good money.» Two goalies - Sam Ersson and Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen - said they'd get rid of the shootout. (Tomas Hertl liked that, too.) If the shootout stays, Pastrnak said the game-winning goal should count to a scorer's individual total as is done in Europe. Hischier likes more European games. Aho and Nino Niederreiter wanted a return to one-versus-eight playoff seeding in each conference.

Despite its controversial nature, the shootout remains a favorite among some fans for its dramatic conclusion to tied games. However, the growing concerns among players suggest that it might be time for the NHL to reconsider the rule. As discussions continue, the league may need to weigh the entertainment value of the shootout against its perceived fairness and impact on player statistics.

Source Sportsnet:
32 Thoughts: A collection of late off-season notes}»

POLL
AOUT 26 \| 103 ANSWERS NHL stars push for Gary Bettman to abolish the league's most disputed rule Should Gary Bettman and the NHL consider replacing the shootout?
Yes	77	74.8 %
No	26	25.2 %
List of polls